The blog of Amon Warmann: Film journalist.

Film Review | Jack Ryan: Shadow Recruit



Following on from predecessors Alec Baldwin, Harrison Ford and Ben Affleck, Chris Pine is the latest actor to take on the mantle of the late Tom Clancy’s CIA analyst in Kenneth Branagh’s Jack Ryan: Shadow Recruit (2014), a safe series reboot which takes the character unsurprisingly back to his roots.

We are first reintroduced to our eponymous hero as just another helpless college student watching 9/11 before fast-forwarding three years to a marine-clad Ryan serving in Afghanistan. When he is seriously injured on a mission, he has to undergo intense physical therapy to even have a hope of walking again. It’s here he meets Dr. Cathy Muller (Keira Knightley) and shadowy agent Thomas Harper (Kevin Costner). Ten years pass, and Jack is working as an undercover CIA analyst in Wall Street ferreting out possible terrorist threats by analysing data whilst also trying to convince Cathy, now his girlfriend, to marry him.

All this occurs in the film’s opening twenty, and the time shifts mean that it takes a while for Shadow Recruit to find its rhythm. Things start to click once the action moves to Moscow, where Ryan is sent to investigate an up to no good corporation headed by Viktor Cherevin (Branagh) after he discovers some fiscal irregularities. Ambushed soon after he touches down, the bruising fight scene and the devastating psychological after-effects for Ryan is, by a distance, the film’s finest segment. Out of his element and forced into action for the first time, it’s a refreshingly non-flippant attitude to the spy game.


Sadly for screenwriters Adam Cozad and David Koepp, it seems an insecure secret agent does not a good action movie make, and before long Ryan is essentially executing all the Bond-like manoeuvres inherent in many an action film that has come before it. A Ryan who was gradually accepting what being a field agent sometimes entails could have made for rich storytelling. Instead, it’s as though we’ve gotten chapters A, B, and C of the Jack Ryan story and then skipped to the part where he’s not only very much at ease with doing what needs to be done, but very adept at doing it. It’s at this point where Shadow Recruit starts to regress into another generic actioner, albeit one that has slickly executed action set pieces and holds the attention.

It helps that Pine turns in another engaging leading man performance. His action chops are unsurprisingly convincing, but it’s the all too brief moments as an out of his depth analyst that he is at his impressively controlled best. He shares easy chemistry with both his co-stars; Costner, in a role that doesn’t stretch him one bit, makes Harper a likable mentor, and though Knightley is saddled with some poor dialogue, there are a few contrived sequences where Cathy is put to good use. Finally, as the talky villain of the piece, Branagh’s Cherevin turns out to be one of the more layered antagonists of times past.

Fancied as the start of a new series, Jack Ryan: Shadow Recruit is a watchable action flick with many enjoyable elements. Even so, from what we’ve seen so far there isn’t enough of a unique selling point to make any announcements of future instalments feel like a truly exciting prospect.

This review was originally published at CineVue.

2 responses

  1. Good review Amon. Being that this is an action movie, released in the dead of January, I expected a whole lot worse. However though, thankfully, I got something that was a bit better and more entertaining to watch. Not a perfect movie, but fine to spend an-hour-and-a-half with.


    January 24, 2014 at 3:34 pm

    • Thanks Dan. Yup, there have been far worse action movies than this in recent times. At least this one holds the attention.


      January 24, 2014 at 3:36 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s