The blog of Amon Warmann: Film journalist.

Film Review | Transcendence



Helmed by Christopher Nolan’s longtime DoP Wally Pfister and packing an all-star cast, there were plenty of reasons to be excited about Transcendence (2014). Sadly, the end result is a disappointing mess of a movie which fails to deliver on its strong premise.

Transcendence follows Will Caster (Johnny Depp), one of the leading minds in artificial intelligence research along with his wife Evelyn (Rebecca Hall). That makes them the target of anti-tech extremists, and an assassination attempt leaves Will wounded and dying from a radioactive bullet. With time running out, Evelyn and colleague Max (Paul Bettany) hatch a desperate plan to upload Will’s consciousness into an experimental A.I. Evelyn and Max ultimately succeed in their Neuromancer-esque goal, but as Will’s thirst for knowledge and power grows stronger, technological advancement soon gives way to fear and paranoia.

It’s an ambitious script from first-time screenwriter Jack Paglen, one which attempts to combine a powerful love story with an examination of technological advancement and its dangers. Unfortunately, it’s only semi-successful. While the core concepts of Transcendence and the questions they pose are inherently interesting, the manner in which the themes are explored feels extremely superficial. Rather than grapple with the thought that Will’s ‘transcendence’ has world-altering benefits, it’s quickly decided that the pioneering scientist’s newfound powers can only possibly yield a catastrophic outcome for humanity.


Coupled with the fact that the film begins with a flash forward before jumping back to how it all began, it robs the film of any suspense. Indeed, once Will is a computer there is very little by way of dramatic momentum, and by the time the energetic third act comes along it’s too little, too late. Worse than that, there are a number of plot holes which make Pfister’s Transcendence easy to pull apart. If you’re going to have a two year time jump, you need to make sure you have all your bases covered. In this regard, the lack of a media presence or seemingly any government hierarchy is suspect. The world of the film – beautifully shot though it may be – feels small for issues which have globe-spanning ramifications.

An outside view of Will and Evelyn’s off-the-grid experiment comes from stock characters inhabited by Kate Mara and fellow Nolan alumni Morgan Freeman and Cillian Murphy. It all amounts to a lot of wasted talent, with character development in short supply. As for Depp, his past charm and eccentricity nowhere to be found, and the difference between his human and digital personae is minuscule. The standout performers are easily Hall and Bettany; the former handles the emotional drama convincingly throughout, whilst Bettany’s Max is by far the most well-rounded character of the piece.

That’s not a high bar to clear, however, and can’t save Transcendence from being a dull and uninvolving affair.

This review was originally published at CineVue.

2 responses

  1. Tackles so many ideas that it never knows what it wants to do with them, nor what it even wants to say. Shame, too, because there could have been some really good stuff here, had everybody involved decided to know what to do. Good review Amon.


    April 28, 2014 at 6:20 pm

  2. I held hope that this would be a good film and that it’d give me a chance to like Johnny Depp again, but pretty much everyone agrees that it sucks. Great review, Amon!


    April 29, 2014 at 1:19 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s